MyFitnessPal or Lose It!: which calorie counter to choose in 2026?

MyFitnessPal and Lose It! have been competing for the calorie-counting market for over a decade. Two American apps, two similar philosophies, a few key differences. Here’s the full breakdown to help you choose.

Detailed comparison table

FeatureFoodCraftMyFitnessPalLose It!
Recipe adjustments for your goals
Photo → instant recipesPremium
Smart Meal PlanningPremium
Personal nutrition supportPremium
Calorie TrackingPremium
Recipe Database
Macronutrient TrackingPremium
Automatic Grocery ListPremium
Multilingual (14 languages)
Free Version
Ad-free
Barcode Scanner
Weight Tracking

MyFitnessPal in detail

Strengths

The global benchmark for nutrition tracking. Gigantic database. Very wide connectivity ecosystem (watches, apps, scales). Macro tracking available for free.

Weaknesses

Dated interface. Aggressive ads. Variable quality of the community database. Premium is expensive compared to the features added.

Lose It! in detail

Strengths

More modern and colorful interface than MFP. 'Snap It' feature to photograph meals. Well-structured weight loss goals. Integration with Apple and Google health apps.

Weaknesses

Macro tracking reserved for Premium. Smaller database than MFP. Very oriented toward the US market. No European ingredient base.

What if neither was enough?

MFP and Lose It! are two sides of the same coin: calorie counters. They measure what you've already eaten. FoodCraft does the opposite: it checks what you're going to eat against your goals. Recipes are adjusted, meal plans are provided, and nutrition becomes practical.

Recipes checked against your needs

Your favorite recipes, adjusted to your macros. Neither MFP nor Lose It! offer this feature.

International and multilingual

Both apps are very US-centric. FoodCraft is available in 14 languages with recipes adapted to all types of cuisine.

Free macros, no compromises

Lose It! locks macros behind a paywall. MFP includes them but with ads. FoodCraft offers free macro tracking with zero ads.

Verdict

Between the two, MyFitnessPal wins for its database and free macros. Lose It! appeals with its interface and 'Snap It' feature. But if you're looking for more than just a counter — an app that helps you cook better, not just count — FoodCraft offers a more modern and practical approach.

Move beyond simple counting

FoodCraft adapts your recipes to your macros. No more counting — just cook exactly what you need.

Try FoodCraft for free

Free · No commitment · 30 seconds

Frequently Asked Questions

Which app is best for weight loss?
All three allow for effective calorie tracking for weight loss. MFP and Lose It! count what you eat. FoodCraft goes further by adapting your recipes to your deficit goal.
Is Snap It comparable to recipe suggestions from a photo?
No. Snap It estimates the calories of a photographed meal (logging). FoodCraft suggests recipes checked against your macros based on a photo (creation). Different goals.
MFP or Lose It! for international users?
MFP is generally the better choice due to its larger database. However, FoodCraft is natively multilingual with 14 supported languages.
Do all three apps work with Apple Watch?
MFP and Lose It! have Apple Watch apps. FoodCraft is a progressive web app accessible on all devices.

Related reading